Developer Telltale caught fiddling Metacritic scores

At least two developers employed at Californian studio Telltale Games wrote glowing reviews for their new game under the guise of impartial consumers.

A user interface artist at Telltale, as well as a cinematic artist, both gave their game a perfect user score on reviews aggregator Metacritic.

One described the game as a mix between Heavy Rain & LA Noire”, and appears to have made the same comment two days later in a separate review under a different name.

Five perfect-score user reviews were published within two days of the game’s release. At the same time, there had been only a single authorised professional review published on the site.

Develop has a lot more detail on the whole sorry saga.

About MCV Staff

Check Also

Games Day 2026 Header Artwork [Industry news] GTA creators reunite for landmark Scottish games industry event

[Industry news] GTA creators reunite for landmark Scottish games industry event

The Scottish Game Developers Association (SGDA) is proud to announce the return of Games Day 2026, a landmark one‑day event coming to Dundee on Friday 25 September. Building on the success of last year's event alongside DICE Europe, the 2026 edition will unite the creators behind Grand Theft Auto, senior leaders from global studios and platforms, and Scotland's thriving community of independent developers for a day of talks, panels, showcases, and networking.